Free-to-use and commercially available climate scenario tools can help make it easier for investors to implement a key recommendation of the TCFD – scenario planning.

The PRI has been partnering with a number of think tanks and academic institutions to help develop and popularise such tools. Notably:

  • The Paris Agreement Capital Transition Assessment (PACTA) tool, which provides portfolio-level analysis of transition risk in public equities and corporate bonds, and uses asset-level data.
  • The Transition Pathway Initiative (TPI) – sector-level analysis of companies’ management of carbon emissions and alignment with the Paris Agreement. TPI uses company-disclosed data.
  • 2 Degrees of Separation – company and sector-level analysis of the oil and gas sector, using asset-level data.

These tools can help accelerate the pace at which investors can start to explore climate scenario analysis and promote further innovation and evolution of the sector. In addition to the tools above, the PRI has been collecting information on commercially-available tools developed by service providers. This is a rapidly-evolving space and below is a table of providers that the PRI is currently aware of. Contact edward.baker@unpri.org with any questions.

Publicly-available tools supported by the PRI

ProviderDescription and coverageMethodologyAccess and deliveryOutputs

2⁰ Investing Initiative

Portfolio-level analysis for equities and fixed income climate transition risks in power and some industrial sectors (cement and steel).

Transition risks only.

Based on asset-level data analyses, the deviation of a portfolio from an optimally diversified portfolio in terms of energy and technologies under the 2-degree pathway as defined by the IEA, Greenpeace and Bloomberg New Energy Finance.

Further details can be found here.

Free, online tool.

Source code will be made publicly available.

Graphical representation of current and future (next five years) alignment with 2-degree benchmarks and industry peers.

30-page report.

The Transition Pathway Initiative (of which PRI is secretariat)

Bottom-up assessment of how listed companies are preparing for the transition to a low-carbon economy.

Transition risks only.

Evaluates and tracks the quality of companies’ management of their GHG emissions and of risks and opportunities related to the low-carbon transition.

Evaluates how companies’ future carbon performance would compare to the international targets and national pledges made as part of the Paris Agreement.

Tools, research and reports are available here.

In-depth sector analysis of industrial sectors (including steel, mining and automotive).

2 Degrees of Separation - Carbon Tracker and the PRI

In-depth sector and company-level analysis of oil and gas companies’ upstream exposure to climate transition risks.

Transition risks only.

 

Uses asset-level data to examine whether the supply options of the largest publicly-traded oil and gas producers are aligned with demand levels consistent with a 2 degree carbon budget. It identifies which companies have the highest exposure to potential capital expenditure through 2025 unaligned with a 2 degree scenario.

Report publicly available online.

Analytical reports, online resources for PRI signatories.

Service provider tools 

ProviderDescription and coverageMethodologyAccess and deliveryOutputs

Carbon Delta

Carbon Delta has developed a database with climate change analysis for over 22,000 publicly-listed companies, covering equities and corporate bonds with a total of over 300,000 securities.

Carbon Delta uses a hybrid top-down and bottom-up approach to climate change scenario modeling. It is top-down due to obtaining national emission reduction targets from NDCs, and assigning the targets to sectors and then companies. It is bottom-up via the estimation of emission reduction requirements for companies at the facility level, using a proprietary asset level database. The physical climate analysis also uses a similar, hybrid approach to climate analysis.

Available commercially on a subscription or project basis. Online, terminal access to Carbon Delta’s analysis will be available in early 2019.  At that time, a free trial will be available, including sample data. 

 

To interpret climate change scenarios, Carbon Delta turns future cost and profit calculations into a meaningful, forward-looking financial metric for investors. By calculating a Climate VaR per security and per scenario, Carbon Delta’s analysis helps investors take the necessary action for risk reporting purposes or optimising risk management and market research processes.

The Climate VaR can be aggregated across asset classes of a portfolio to actively or passively manage assets with insights into climate change risks and opportunities. Carbon Delta currently has a VaR model based on future costs or profits for listed equities and probability of default analysis for corporate bonds.

Carbone 4

Transition risk: Carbon Impact Analytics (CIA) is a methodology for assessing the climate impact of portfolios through the measurement of GHG emissions directly and indirectly induced and saved by companies.

CIA also asses the alignment of investor and lender portfolios with the Paris 2° objective.

Carbone 4 finance also provides Physical risk evaluation of these issuers with Climate Risk Impact Screening (CRIS).

The CRIS method allows asset managers and investors to know the level of risk in their portfolios so that they can manage this risk, track it over time and engage in dialogue with the underlying companies about their vulnerability to climate change.

Coverage: equities; bonds and green bonds of corporates; and sovereigns around the world.

CIA: methodology specific by sector, based on a bottom-up analysis of the operating data of each portfolio constituent before aggregation at the portfolio level.

We complement the quantitative analysis of current performance with a qualitative analysis of a company’s climate strategy.

 

Further details can be found here

 

The CRIS method enables the provision of a physical risk rating at the issuer and portfolio level, which incorporates a climate component and a sectoral and contextual vulnerability component.

More information is availble here.

 

These methods apply to multi-asset investment portfolios (stocks, corporate and sovereign bonds and real assets).

Online access to CIA database;

Portfolio analysis report; and

Access to CRIS database.

Identify corporates and sovereigns which have a high transition and/or physical risk. Identify best-in-class corporates or companies which strongly contribute to decarbonisation and will create value. CIA and CRIS results can be used to :

  • support strategic decision of investors in portfolio  construction;
  • develop thematic or sector-specific investment strategies;
  • measure climate-related risks in loan books or investment portfolios; and
  • create indices or benchmarks based on climate performance.

 

ClimateWise

ClimateWise Transition Risk framework.

Purpose: framework to assess the impact of transition risk and opportunity on the financial performance of investments in infrastructure at the portfolio and asset level.

Coverage: includes a step-by-step guide and case studies for investors to:

  • assess the breadth of asset types exposed to transition risk and opportunity;
  • define potential impact of transition risk at the asset level; and
  • incorporate transition impacts into an asset financial model.

Assesses how the costs and revenue drivers of assets could be impacted by the low-carbon transition, considering sectors, geographies and time frames.

Adaptable framework to meet investors’ specific needs - a variety of transition scenarios, time frames and asset types could be applied.

Open-source framework.

Navigating the Transition open-source framework step-by-step guide to:

  • inform investors and regulators on the future allocation of funds and diversification of investment portfolios;
  • indicate investment options for asset managers and owners to help improve asset resilience; and
  • enable quantification of potential impact on asset returns, investment options or exit strategies.

ERM

Key services offered:

  • Top-down portfolio screening. Both transition and physical risks are considered.
  • Bottom-up analysis of assets. The analysis could include identification of asset-specific financial drivers and creation of scenarios for asset financial models to understand financial impact.
  • Creation of a dashboard to monitor signpost market indicators within a sector that indicate an inflection point or movement, enabling quick responses and exposure adjustments.
  • Detailed asset-specific consideration of vulnerability and resilience to physical climate hazards, including development of adaptation plans.

Key elements of the methodology:

  • ERM has a suite of internal proprietary tools which are used to analyse financial opportunities and risks related to the low-carbon transition, and translate these into financial drivers and impacts. A complementary toolkit is used to assess physical climate threats. These tools are applied to the client’s portfolio in order to undertake the analysis.
  • ERM’s methodology is aligned with the recommendations of the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD). 

Available commercially on a project basis.

Key outputs:

  • Top-down portfolio screening
  • Bottom-up analysis of assets
  • The creation of a risk management dashboard
  • Asset specific physical climate change risk assessment

 

 

Four Twenty Seven

Bottom-up climate risk scores for global equities, fixed income, sovereign and real assets.

 

Physical climate risk.

Scores measure exposure and sensitivity to climate impacts (storms, droughts, floods, heat waves, wildfires, sea level rises) at the facility-level for publicly-listed companies and real asset portfolios. Focuses on exposure to tail risks and change from current conditions against a 2020-2040 timeframe.

More details: white paper on physical risk in Equities and U.S. Munis.

Available commercially as a data feed or via a secure visualisation and analytics platform, as well as for reporting and bespoke analytical projects.

Identify assets, sectors and geographies most vulnerable to physical impacts of climate change. Build a risk mitigation strategy and resilience plan based on granular assessment. Perform due diligence for new asset acquisition.

ISS – Climate

ISS-Climate offers impact and risk-oriented scenario analysis at the company, total portfolio and sector level, and is available for different asset classes. To date, eight scenario approaches are available.

Impact – allowing an investor to assess how investments contribute to the 2o C goal, and with which climate scenarios they align.

Risk – allowing an investor to assess exposure to transition and physical risks, and potential financial impacts from those risks. 

The approaches build on established methodologies, including:

Carbon Yield

Sectoral Decarbonisation Approach & Science Based Targets

- ISS-ekom Sustainability Solutions Assessment

ISS-oekom Carbon Risk Rating

- Climate scenarios developed by International Energy Agency Energy Technology Perspectives

Available commercially on a project or subscription basis with optional advisory services to support investor understanding and implementation.

Delivered as raw data or in a report containing the individual outputs (charts, graphs and descriptions) of the chosen assessments. Advisory services are available.

Analyse potential impacts and highest risks within the portfolio to support the development of appropriate strategies and plans for action.

 

Mercer

Top-down, asset allocation climate scenario tool that examines risk/return impacts at total portfolio, asset class and sector level.

Transition and physical impact risks.

Development of climate scenario pathways and risk/return sensitivities of asset classes and industry sectors to TRIP climate risk factors (technology, resource availability, impact and policy).

Further details can be found here.

 

Available commercially on a project basis, client retainer agreement or through a research partner arrangement for asset owners.

Identify priority risks and opportunities and the potential relative impacts under different climate scenarios (including 2 degrees or less) to support strategic decision making on asset allocation and portfolio construction.

Trucost, part of S&P Dow Jones Indices

Trucost’s Carbon Earning at Risk assesses companies’ exposures to evolving regional carbon pricing mechanisms (including implicit regulations including fuel and other taxes) up to 2030.

 

Transition risks.

Trucost has curated a global database of current carbon regulations, emissions trading schemes, fuel and other taxes, and potential future carbon pricing scenarios designed to achieve the goals of the Paris Agreement to limit global warming to 2°C or less.

The regional carbon pricing information is then combined with a company’s greenhouse gas emissions and financial performance data to provide insights on carbon pricing risks to 2030.

The tool models the progressive closure of the spread between carbon prices today and in the future, considering science-based scenarios and climate change commitments.

Available commercially on a project basis or as part of Trucost’s environmental data subscription (for example, portfolio carbon footprinting) for asset owners and asset managers.

Identify carbon price risk premium (expressed in impact on EBITDA and/or profit margin) of individual companies and at the portfolio level. This supports company selection and engagement activities for asset managers.

This complements other portfolio climate risk indicators provided by Trucost, such as exposure to stranded assets and alignment with 2 degrees scenario.